Tasting Test: Protein Startups Offer Mediocre Snacks And Drinks
A taste test of various protein snacks and drinks from venture-backed startups reveals that while these products successfully deliver high nutritional value, their flavors and textures generally fall short compared to traditional alternatives.
Ideally, our daily meals and snacks would be convenient, exceptionally flavorful, and nutritionally optimal.
Practically speaking, however, compromises are inevitable. We tend to crave ice cream, potato chips, and candy bars, which make carbohydrates and fat very easy to overconsume. Meanwhile, reaching daily protein targets requires deliberate effort, especially for individuals—such as the author—who prefer not to eat large quantities of meat.
Fortunately, as noted earlier this week, both startup enterprises and legacy food corporations are making it easier than ever to increase protein consumption. Ranging from sodas to snack bars and ice cream, it is now entirely possible to obtain this sought-after macronutrient through foods and beverages typically associated with sugar, starch, and fat.
The burning question remains: Do these products actually taste good? To find out, we visited a local Target store to purchase an assortment of protein products created by venture-backed startups. The author and a 10-year-old companion then put them through a formal taste test.
The conclusion? Most of these items are indeed edible and drinkable, though rarely as delicious as their lower-protein alternatives, save for one distinct exception.
Our evaluation follows:
No. 1: David Vanilla Bean Frozen Dessert: Anyone who purchases or eats this specific ice cream alternative does so for the nutritional value rather than the flavor. A single pint delivers an impressive 30 grams of protein alongside only 210 calories. Furthermore, the texture hits the mark—it is creamy, easy to scoop, and features a clear vanilla taste.
Even so, you cannot overlook the fact that this is not crafted from traditional ice cream ingredients. Consumers who dislike artificial sweeteners or the taste and consistency of whey protein will likely want to skip it. For the evaluators, however, it provided a reasonably pleasant eating experience. It falls short of traditional ice cream, but stands out as quite respectable for a high-protein food.
Made by: Medici Brands (David’s parent company)
No. 2 SkyPop Protein Soda: The nutritional metrics for SkyPop Protein Soda are similarly striking. A 12-ounce can contains just 45 calories, paired with 10 grams of protein and a single gram of carbohydrates. It also offers proper carbonation, producing a satisfying hiss upon opening.
Yet how does it taste? Our neighborhood store stocked only the Ice Pop flavor, which—in the opinion of both tasters—was not awful, though certainly not something we would purchase on a regular basis. I could imagine drinking it while following a clear liquid diet ahead of medical procedures, as it represents one of the few viable protein sources available in that format.
Made by: SkyPop (formerly Don’t Quit)
No. 3: Khloud Protein Popcorn: Unlike several other items on our list, Khloud Protein Popcorn is not an intensely protein-dense product. A standard portion supplies 7 grams of protein and 160 calories, with the majority derived from carbs and fat. Nevertheless, its protein content exceeds that of conventional packaged popcorn, which typically delivers roughly 2 grams of protein per comparable serving.
Ultimately, the tasters determined that the White Cheddar variety of Khloud is a satisfactory snack food. The presence of milk protein and whey protein concentrate was noticeable, though not overpowering. While it may not be a snack to savor deeply, it fulfills its purpose for casual munching at a desk or while watching television.
Made by: Khloud
No. 4 Mosh: In season three of “The White Lotus,” Mosh co-founder Patrick Schwarzenegger portrays a fitness and finance enthusiast who blends a daily high-protein shake that his family members find repulsive. This may well have drawn inspiration from Mosh, the brain-supporting protein bar startup he established alongside his mother, Maria Shriver.
The Mosh bar, evaluated here in the peanut butter cup variety, packs 20 grams of protein, 6 grams of fiber, and brain-focused additives like creatine and lion’s mane into a portable, shelf-stable format. It is a remarkable technical achievement. However, while our brains may have welcomed the nutritional and supplement enhancement delivered by the Mosh bar, our taste buds firmly rejected it.
I would classify Mosh firmly within the functional food category. It represents something you might consume if you specifically sought that exact combination of nutrients, rather than something eaten purely for enjoyment.
Made by: Mosh
No. 5 Cadootz Crackers: We sampled two variations of Cadootz Crackers—cheddar and sea salt—and emerged feeling neither enthusiastic nor deterred.
For individuals seeking a gluten-free and seed-oil-free snack cracker delivering roughly 5 grams of protein per serving, Cadootz fits the criteria well. It offers a pleasant crunch and an acceptable flavor profile.
As someone who does not actively avoid gluten and seed oils or require a minor protein boost from crackers, I will likely bypass future purchases. Yet for its intended demographic, Cadootz should perform admirably.
Made by: Cadootz!
No. 6 Frozen One: For those who viewed the David frozen dessert as a masterpiece of nutritional engineering, the team behind Frozen One has a counteroffer. Their protein ice cream boasts a massive 40 grams of protein per pint.
Indeed, but how does it taste? Not terribly, according to our two-person testing panel. We tested both the chocolate and apple pie flavors, favoring the chocolate option. Similar to the David product, Frozen One tastes strongly of milk protein concentrate and sugar substitutes. You will never mistake it for Ben & Jerry’s. But if the objective is to consume a steak-equivalent amount of protein packaged inside a pint of ice cream, it accomplishes the task.
Made by: Frozen One
No. 7 Brami Protein Pasta: We saved our top pick for last. Unexpectedly, that honor went to Brami Protein Pasta, a noodle fashioned from semolina and lupini beans that features approximately 70% more protein than standard pasta and more than double the fiber.
Providing roughly 12 grams of protein per 200-calorie portion, Brami is not an ultra-dense protein source. Still, paired with an appropriate sauce, it successfully transforms a typically carbohydrate-heavy noodle dish into a reasonably protein-conscious meal.
Most importantly, Brami actually tastes quite good, devoid of any noticeable off-flavors or textural anomalies. I prepared both traditional noodles and Brami noodles to evaluate the difference side by side. When going back for seconds, I chose the Brami.
Made by: Brami
Related Crunchbase query:
- Protein Snacks And Packaged Foods Startups
Related reading:
- VCs Are Still Chasing Protein, Even As Fake Meat Falls Out Of Favor
Illustration: Dom Guzman
?Frequently Asked Questions
01Do protein snacks taste as good as regular snacks?
Generally, taste tests show that high-protein alternatives are edible and acceptable, but they rarely match the flavor and texture of traditional, sugar- and fat-heavy foods.
02Which protein startup product tasted the best in the sample?
Out of all the items tested, Brami Protein Pasta was rated the best, offering good flavor and texture without weird aftertastes compared to standard pasta.
03Are all protein-packed foods low in calories?
Not necessarily. While some items like SkyPop Soda and David Frozen Dessert manage high protein with low calories, others like snack bars and popcorn still carry significant calorie counts from fats and carbohydrates.
Financial Disclaimer: The content provided in this article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or nutritional advice. Investing in startups, venture capital funds, or food and beverage companies involves substantial risk of loss. Always conduct your own thorough research and consult with a qualified professional before making any financial or investment decisions.



